Retssager om altaner
Altansager vedrører tre retsområder: forvaltningsret, foreningsret og naboret
Forvaltningsretten kommer i spil, når kommunen giver byggetilladelse til en altan, der er i strid med overordnede regler som fx Planloven, eller når kommunen svigter sit ansvar for at partshøre naboer om de gener, altaner vil medføre. I disse tilfælde er der en række klagemuligheder, som skal udtømmes, før kommunen stævnes.
Naboret
Den naboretlige tålegrænse.
'%20fill%3D'%23092d7e'%20fill-rule%3D'nonzero'%3E%3Cg%20id%3D'img-quote'%20transform%3D'translate(934.000000,%201405.000000)'%3E%3Cpath%20d%3D'M27,0%20C12.0810811,0%200,12.0629685%200,26.9595202%20C0,31.4122939%201.05405405,35.6221889%203,39.3463268%20L0,54%20L14.5945946,51.0044978%20C18.3243243,52.9475262%2022.5405405,54%2027,54%20C41.9189189,54%2054,41.9370315%2054,27.0404798%20C54,11.982009%2041.9189189,0%2027,0%20Z%20M27,52.2188906%20C22.9459459,52.2188906%2019.0540541,51.2473763%2015.4864865,49.3853073%20L14.9189189,49.0614693%20L14.3513514,49.1424288%20L2.35135135,51.5712144%20L4.78378378,39.6701649%20L4.86486486,39.1034483%20L4.54054054,38.5367316%20C2.67567568,34.8935532%201.7027027,31.0074963%201.7027027,26.9595202%20C1.7027027,13.0344828%2012.972973,1.78067842%2026.9189189,1.78067842%20C40.8648649,1.70014993%2052.1355699,13.0344828%2052.1355699,26.9595202%20C52.2162162,40.8845577%2040.9459459,52.2188906%2027,52.2188906%20Z'%20id%3D'Shape'%2F%3E%3Cg%20id%3D'Group'%20transform%3D'translate(18.000000,%2020.000000)'%3E%3Cpath%20d%3D'M8,1.65745856%20C7.11111111,2.15469613%206.46464646,2.56906077%205.8989899,2.98342541%20C5.41414141,3.31491713%204.84848485,3.8121547%204.28282828,4.39226519%20C3.7979798,4.88950276%203.39393939,5.46961326%203.15151515,6.13259669%20C2.90909091,6.71270718%202.66666667,7.54143646%202.58585859,8.5359116%20L3.87878788,8.5359116%20C5.01010101,8.5359116%205.8989899,8.78453039%206.54545455,9.36464088%20C7.19191919,9.94475138%207.51515152,10.7734807%207.51515152,11.8508287%20C7.51515152,12.5966851%207.19191919,13.3425414%206.62626263,14.0055249%20C6.06060606,14.6685083%205.25252525,15%204.28282828,15%20C2.74747475,15%201.61616162,14.5027624%200.96969697,13.4254144%20C0.323232323,12.3480663%200,11.0220994%200,9.28176796%20C0,8.03867403%200.242424242,6.96132597%200.727272727,5.96685083%20C1.21212121,4.97237569%201.85858586,4.06077348%202.58585859,3.31491713%20C3.31313131,2.48618785%204.12121212,1.82320442%204.92929293,1.32596685%20C5.73737374,0.745856354%206.46464646,0.331491713%207.03030303,0%20L8,1.65745856%20Z'%20id%3D'Shape'%2F%3E%3Cpath%20d%3D'M19,1.58333333%20C18.1111111,2.08333333%2017.4646465,2.5%2016.8989899,2.91666667%20C16.4141414,3.25%2015.8484848,3.75%2015.2828283,4.33333333%20C14.7979798,4.83333333%2014.3939394,5.41666667%2014.1515152,6.08333333%20C13.9090909,6.66666667%2013.6666667,7.5%2013.5858586,8.5%20L14.8787879,8.5%20C16.010101,8.5%2016.8989899,8.75%2017.5454545,9.33333333%20C18.1919192,9.91666667%2018.5151515,10.75%2018.5151515,11.8333333%20C18.5151515,12.5833333%2018.1919192,13.3333333%2017.6262626,14%20C17.0606061,14.6666667%2016.2525253,15%2015.2828283,15%20C13.7474747,15%2012.6161616,14.5%2011.969697,13.4166667%20C11.3232323,12.3333333%2011,11%2011,9.25%20C11,8%2011.2424242,6.91666667%2011.7272727,5.91666667%20C12.2121212,5%2012.7777778,4.16666667%2013.5050505,3.33333333%20C14.2323232,2.5%2015.040404,1.83333333%2015.8484848,1.33333333%20C16.6565657,0.75%2017.3838384,0.333333333%2017.9494949,0%20L19,1.58333333%20Z'%20id%3D'Shape'%2F%3E%3C%2Fg%3E%3C%2Fg%3E%3C%2Fg%3E%3C%2Fg%3E%3C%2Fsvg%3E)
Jeg har som privatrådgiver for andelslejlighedskøbere indimellem set foreninger, hvor et altanprojekt er vedtaget med simpelt flertal. Som allerede anført, mener jeg, at da der rådes over foreningens ejendom – facaderne – fordrer en vedtagelse et kvalificeret flertal.